Beta
314942

Impact of Negative Variance Component Estimates on the Kenward-Roger Test for Fixed Effects in Linear Mixed Models

Article

Last updated: 05 Jan 2025

Subjects

-

Tags

-

Abstract

A well-known procedure to make inference for fixed effects in a normal mixed linear model is the Kenward-Roger procedure (Kenward and Roger 1997), where a scaled Wald type statistic follows approximately an F distribution, and in special cases the test has an exact F test. In the procedure, the estimated denominator degrees of freedom of the F distribution, the estimated scale factor, and the scaled test statistic are calculated based on the data. The variance components of the random terms in the model are estimated by the restricted maximum likelihood (REML) method, in which sometimes the estimates produced are negative. Two methods are usually considered to resolve the issue of negative variance component estimates: to set the negative estimates as zero or to allow them remain negative. Assessing the performance of the procedure with each method based on the test level and power was done analytically and by a simulation study for four different designs. The estimates of the denominator degrees of freedom and scale factor were also calculated and compared for the procedure with each method. We showed that the Kenward-Roger procedure with the method that doesn't constrain the variance component estimates to be non-negative was instable for some data sets with negative variance component estimates, and was excessively conservative for some designs. By setting the negative variance component estimates as zero, the procedure became stable and more adequate than with allowing the estimates remain negative for the designs considered in the simulation study.

DOI

10.21608/esju.2023.187978.1010

Keywords

variance components, Mixed Linear Model, Kenward Roger test, Restricted maximum likelihood estimator, Linear hypothesis

Authors

First Name

Waseem

Last Name

Alnosaier

MiddleName

-

Affiliation

Department of Statistics, Institute of Public Administration.

Email

alnosaierw@ipa.edu.sa

City

Riyadh

Orcid

0000-0002-5253-2637

Volume

67

Article Issue

1

Related Issue

43194

Issue Date

2023-06-01

Receive Date

2023-01-17

Publish Date

2023-06-01

Page Start

1

Page End

18

Print ISSN

0542-1748

Online ISSN

2786-0086

Link

https://esju.journals.ekb.eg/article_314942.html

Detail API

https://esju.journals.ekb.eg/service?article_code=314942

Order

1

Type

Original Article

Type Code

1,914

Publication Type

Journal

Publication Title

The Egyptian Statistical Journal

Publication Link

https://esju.journals.ekb.eg/

MainTitle

Impact of Negative Variance Component Estimates on the Kenward-Roger Test for Fixed Effects in Linear Mixed Models

Details

Type

Article

Created At

28 Dec 2024