Background: Carcinoma of the nasopharynx is one of the most common
cancers in the head and neck areas. Control of the disease at an early stage with
radiotherapy alone is usually successful. However, in loco regionally advanced
disease, concurrent chemo radiotherapy is the standard treatment
As regards the conventional 2dimensional radiotherapy, many studies have
shown equivalent results to intensity modulated radiotherapy on the level of
local, regional and distant disease control while others have reported that
intensity modulated radiotherapy has improved both the overall survival and
local disease control and decreased late toxicities compared to the conventional
2 dimensional radiotherapy.
The aim of the study: Is to compare between intensity modulated radiotherapy
and conventional 2D radiotherapy on the level of treatment outcome and
treatment related morbidities in patients with non metastatic squamous cell
carcinoma of the nasopharynx.
Patients and methods: Patients treated by radiotherapy +/- chemotherapy from
January 2013 to January 2023 in Sohag University Hospital were retrospectively
enrolled and analyzed.
Results: Forty one patients were identified. Twenty one (51%) were treated
with intensity modulated radiotherapy while 20 (49%) were treated with
conventional 2D radiotherapy. Chemotherapy was given in 33 cases (80%). No
significant differences were noticed between both arms on the level of acute and
chronic treatment related toxicities.
The 5-y overall survival (OS), local progression free survival (LPFS) and distant
progression free survival (DPFS) with conventional 2D radiotherapy and
intensity modulated radiotherapy in the whole cohort were 72% versus 64%; p =
0.218 & 63% versus 85%; p = 0.220 and 77% versus 88%; p = 0.449
respectively. In univariate analysis, many significant findings were evident. Age
> 51 y was associated with poorer OS in the whole cohort (p = 0.049) and also
in the subgroup received chemotherapy (p = 0.047). Intensity modulated
radiotherapy has significantly improved the 5-y DPFS in stage II disease
(p=0.049). Chemotherapy significantly improved LPFS in advanced stages
(p=0.012). Irradiation dose at 70 Gy has demonstrated significantly better OS
and LPFS in advanced versus early stage (p = 0.041 and 0.012 respectively) and
lastly male patients have shown significantly lower OS (p=0.041) compared to
females in the older subgroup of patients. In multivariate analysis, younger age
was associated with significantly better 5-y OS versus older age in the subgroup
received concurrent chemo radiotherapy (HR: 0.123; 95% CI: 0.021 – 0.712 & p
= 0.019).
Conclusions: Although this retrospective study has enrolled a small number of
patients, we conclude that in early stage of cancer nasopharynx, intensity
modulated radiotherapy alone is successful and preferable than conventional
radiotherapy while in advanced stages both chemotherapy (preferably, both
induction and concurrent) and high dose radiation therapy should be considered.
Younger ages associated with better survival outcome and, more studies are
needed to improve the outcome in elderly male patients.