Beta
395062

The Problem of Culture Specificity in Translation: A Study of the Published English Versions of Some of Noamaan Ashour's Plays

Article

Last updated: 04 Jan 2025

Subjects

-

Tags

-

Abstract

This research paper attempts to demonstrate the mediating role the translator is entrusted with and the efforts undertaken by him/her to transcend cultural barriers. Two plays written by the renowned Egyptian dramatist Noamaan Ashour feature high on this research because they are heavily laden with culture-bound expressions that mirror the Egyptian cultural milieu. The present research explores the strategies devised by the translator to come to terms with the problem of culture-specific items. These items pose a challenge to the translator since they are so deeply embedded in the source culture that the translator may find it difficult to render them into the Target Language (TL). Each translation strategy has its merits and demerits: cultural substitution is a reasonable strategy, but it entails that the translator should carefully consider equivalents and the hierarchy of correspondences so as to adapt the values of the Source Language (SL) cultural system to the values of the TL cultural system. Translation by paraphrase is another tenable strategy, but it is sometimes cumbersome for the translator to break up a lexical item into several words and cover all its shades of meaning. The option of paraphrase may reduce the degree of transparency in Target Text (TT) since the addition of a paraphrase alerts the TL readers that the lexical item in question does not exist in their cultural matrix. Further, the strategy of cultural borrowing entails carrying across the meaning of cultural specifics verbatim into the TT. It thus involves the insertion of footnotes having explanatory material, and transliteration. This strategy may break the flow of thoughts of the TL readers since they will have to consult the footnotes while reading. Besides, the translator may run the risk of producing an inadequate definition of the culture-specific item in the footnote. Translation by omission is given due attention in this research as a strategy conducive to creating a smooth and readable Target Text.  Translators should pay heed to the fact that this strategy is not a pretext to evade complex and awkward words and expressions; rather this strategy is justifiably adopted to prevent any degree of miscomprehension on the part of the TL readers. The principle of compensation is demonstrated in this study. Translators are recommended to heed this principle since it seeks to create an understandable imitation of the Source Text (ST).

DOI

10.21608/herms.2016.395062

Keywords

Cultural substitution, paraphrase, cultural borrowing, omission

Authors

First Name

Amr

Last Name

Nour El Din

MiddleName

-

Affiliation

Language Instructor, English Department, Cairo University Supervised by Professor Mohamed Mohamed Enani

Email

-

City

-

Orcid

-

Volume

5

Article Issue

3

Related Issue

51864

Issue Date

2016-07-01

Receive Date

2024-12-04

Publish Date

2016-07-01

Page Start

133

Page End

162

Print ISSN

2090-8555

Online ISSN

2974-4695

Link

https://hermes.journals.ekb.eg/article_395062.html

Detail API

https://hermes.journals.ekb.eg/service?article_code=395062

Order

6

Type

المقالة الأصلية

Type Code

1,100

Publication Type

Journal

Publication Title

هرمس

Publication Link

https://hermes.journals.ekb.eg/

MainTitle

The Problem of Culture Specificity in Translation: A Study of the Published English Versions of Some of Noamaan Ashour's Plays

Details

Type

Article

Created At

25 Dec 2024